Testimony of Captain Bates
Among those who listened to her was a former sea captain, Joseph Bates. A few years earlier he had turned from the sea to become an active worker in the Millerite movement. In fact, he presided at one of the important general conferences of the movement. He was the only prominent Millerite leader who belonged to the small post-Millerite segment of which we are speaking. The fact that for years he had been a sea captain indicated that he belonged to a breed of men generally considered hard-bitten, skeptical, and well acquainted with many kinds and types of people.
WBEGW 16.1
In April, 1847, he published on one side of a single sheet of paper, known as a broadside, the text of one of Mrs. White’s visions. (Later published in Early Writings, 32-35.) The text of the vision takes about three fourths of the space on the page. Following it are “Remarks” by Joseph Bates. We quote his “Remarks” as they appear on the broadside:
WBEGW 16.2
“It is now about two years since I first saw the author, and heard her relate the substance of her visions as she has since published them in Portland (April 6, 1846). Although I could see nothing in them that militated against the word, yet I felt alarmed and tried exceedingly, and for a long time unwilling to believe that it was any thing more than what was produced by a protracted debilitated state of her body.
WBEGW 16.3
“I therefore sought opportunities in presence of others, when her mind seemed freed from excitement, (out of meeting) to question, and cross question her, and her friends which accompanied her, especially her elder sister, to get if possible at the truth. During the number of visits she has made to New Bedford and Fairhaven since, while at our meetings, I have seen her in vision a number of times, and also in Topsham, Me., and those who were present during some of these exciting scenes know well with what interest and intensity I listened to every word, and watched every move to detect deception, or mesmeric influence. And I thank God for the opportunity I have had with others to witness these things. I can now confidently speak for myself. I believe the work is of God, and is given to comfort and strengthen his ‘scattered,’ ‘torn,’ and ‘pealed people,’ since the closing up of our work for the world in October, 1844. The distracted state of lo, heres! and lo, theres! since that time has exceedingly perplexed God’s honest, willing people, and made it exceedingly difficult for such as were not able to expound the many conflicting texts that have been presented to their view. I confess that I have received light and instruction on many passages that I could not before clearly distinguish. I believe her to be a self-sacrificing, honest, willing child of God, and saved, if at all, through her entire obedience to his will.”—Reprinted in A Word to the Little Flock, 21, 1847.
WBEGW 16.4
How revealing these remarks. They picture Bates, not as a credulous man, but as almost a doubting Thomas at the outset. However, after two years his mind was settled, and he concluded that she was what she claimed to be, a handmaiden of God to whom He gave inspired revelations. Bates’s remarks concerning her unique value and significance to the Advent people are also worth noting. He saw Mrs. White’s function as that of a guide, a counselor, an expounder of the Word of God, to lead the people of God forward on the right path, despite distracting “lo, heres! and lo, theres!” Says he: “I confess that I have received light and instruction on many passages that I could not before clearly distinguish.”
WBEGW 17.1
657
WBEGW
Why I Believe in Mrs. E. G. White
[{"para_id":"657.2","title":"Why I Believe in Mrs. E. G. White","mp3":"\/mp3\/657\/0000_eng_f_by_francis_d_nichol_657_2.mp3#duration=14&size=287603"},{"para_id":"657.9","title":"Chapter One\u2014An Unusual People","mp3":"\/mp3\/657\/0001_eng_f_chapter_one_an_unusual_people_657_9.mp3#duration=165&size=1190074"},{"para_id":"657.17","title":"The Prime Question","mp3":"\/mp3\/657\/0002_eng_f_the_prime_question_657_17.mp3#duration=359&size=2355943"},{"para_id":"657.31","title":"Background of Seventh-day Adventists","mp3":"\/mp3\/657\/0003_eng_f_background_of_seventh_day_adventists_657_31.mp3#duration=199&size=1397710"},{"para_id":"657.41","title":"Chapter Two\u2014Truth, Stranger Than Fiction","mp3":"\/mp3\/657\/0004_eng_f_chapter_two_truth_stranger_than_fiction_657_41.mp3#duration=216&size=1497086"},{"para_id":"657.50","title":"Testimony of Captain Bates","mp3":"\/mp3\/657\/0005_eng_f_testimony_of_captain_bates_657_50.mp3#duration=240&size=1641938"},{"para_id":"657.60","title":"No Mass Movement Toward Mrs. White","mp3":"\/mp3\/657\/0006_eng_f_no_mass_movement_toward_mrs_white_657_60.mp3#duration=143&size=1055940"},{"para_id":"657.65","title":"A Significant Bible Prophecy","mp3":"\/mp3\/657\/0007_eng_f_a_significant_bible_prophecy_657_65.mp3#duration=174&size=1245669"},{"para_id":"657.72","title":"A Frank Admission","mp3":"\/mp3\/657\/0008_eng_f_a_frank_admission_657_72.mp3#duration=203&size=1421873"},{"para_id":"657.83","title":"Chapter Three\u2014Saved, From the Folly of Time Setting","mp3":"\/mp3\/657\/0009_eng_f_chapter_three_saved_from_the_folly_of_time_setting_657_83.mp3#duration=169&size=1213095"},{"para_id":"657.90","title":"A Pertinent Question","mp3":"\/mp3\/657\/0010_eng_f_a_pertinent_question_657_90.mp3#duration=569&size=3613088"},{"para_id":"657.115","title":"Chapter Four\u2014Streams of Light Around the World","mp3":"\/mp3\/657\/0011_eng_f_chapter_four_streams_of_light_around_the_world_657_115.mp3#duration=110&size=861190"},{"para_id":"657.121","title":"A Hard Question","mp3":"\/mp3\/657\/0012_eng_f_a_hard_question_657_121.mp3#duration=92&size=750611"},{"para_id":"657.124","title":"First Journal Published","mp3":"\/mp3\/657\/0013_eng_f_first_journal_published_657_124.mp3#duration=190&size=1342434"},{"para_id":"657.132","title":"Only One Answer","mp3":"\/mp3\/657\/0014_eng_f_only_one_answer_657_132.mp3#duration=82&size=690426"},{"para_id":"657.138","title":"Chapter Five\u2014Saved From the Danger of Disintegration","mp3":"\/mp3\/657\/0015_eng_f_chapter_five_saved_from_the_danger_of_disintegration_657_138.mp3#duration=171&size=1228895"},{"para_id":"657.144","title":"Life of Church Threatened","mp3":"\/mp3\/657\/0016_eng_f_life_of_church_threatened_657_144.mp3#duration=184&size=1304772"},{"para_id":"657.153","title":"Looking Back on a Great Event","mp3":"\/mp3\/657\/0017_eng_f_looking_back_on_a_great_event_657_153.mp3#duration=224&size=1545394"},{"para_id":"657.166","title":"A Reasonable Conclusion","mp3":"\/mp3\/657\/0018_eng_f_a_reasonable_conclusion_657_166.mp3#duration=94&size=762689"},{"para_id":"657.170","title":"Chapter Six\u2014Visions on Healthful Living","mp3":"\/mp3\/657\/0019_eng_f_chapter_six_visions_on_healthful_living_657_170.mp3#duration=103&size=818504"},{"para_id":"657.175","title":"Reformers Arise","mp3":"\/mp3\/657\/0020_eng_f_reformers_arise_657_175.mp3#duration=192&size=1355434"},{"para_id":"657.183","title":"A Distinctive Position","mp3":"\/mp3\/657\/0021_eng_f_a_distinctive_position_657_183.mp3#duration=169&size=1215053"},{"para_id":"657.194","title":"Her Selection No Accident","mp3":"\/mp3\/657\/0022_eng_f_her_selection_no_accident_657_194.mp3#duration=76&size=658885"},{"para_id":"657.197","title":"Chapter Seven\u2014Visions on Healthful Living-Continued","mp3":"\/mp3\/657\/0023_eng_f_chapter_seven_visions_on_healthful_living_continued_657_197.mp3#duration=123&size=941285"},{"para_id":"657.203","title":"The Poor \u201cGrass Eaters\u201d","mp3":"\/mp3\/657\/0024_eng_f_the_poor_grass_eaters_657_203.mp3#duration=273&size=1838879"},{"para_id":"657.211","title":"Value of Physical Exercise","mp3":"\/mp3\/657\/0025_eng_f_value_of_physical_exercise_657_211.mp3#duration=100&size=803653"},{"para_id":"657.217","title":"Comments on Cancer","mp3":"\/mp3\/657\/0026_eng_f_comments_on_cancer_657_217.mp3#duration=159&size=1157592"},{"para_id":"657.224","title":"Tobacco is a Poison","mp3":"\/mp3\/657\/0027_eng_f_tobacco_is_a_poison_657_224.mp3#duration=236&size=1616113"},{"para_id":"657.239","title":"Chapter Eight\u2014Eminent Testimony on Mrs. White\u2019s Health Teachings","mp3":"\/mp3\/657\/0028_eng_f_chapter_eight_eminent_testimony_on_mrs_white_s_health_teachings_657_239.mp3#duration=320&size=2123878"},{"para_id":"657.255","title":"A University Professor Speaks","mp3":"\/mp3\/657\/0029_eng_f_a_university_professor_speaks_657_255.mp3#duration=147&size=1084831"},{"para_id":"657.260","title":"Summary by Dr. McCay","mp3":"\/mp3\/657\/0030_eng_f_summary_by_dr_mccay_657_260.mp3#duration=164&size=1186150"},{"para_id":"657.272","title":"Chapter Nine\u2014Schools and Foreign Missions Begin","mp3":"\/mp3\/657\/0031_eng_f_chapter_nine_schools_and_foreign_missions_begin_657_272.mp3#duration=143&size=1059036"},{"para_id":"657.279","title":"Testimony of Dr. Stratemeyer","mp3":"\/mp3\/657\/0032_eng_f_testimony_of_dr_stratemeyer_657_279.mp3#duration=215&size=1492528"},{"para_id":"657.290","title":"Adventist Mission Program","mp3":"\/mp3\/657\/0033_eng_f_adventist_mission_program_657_290.mp3#duration=90&size=740167"},{"para_id":"657.296","title":"The Inspired Challenger","mp3":"\/mp3\/657\/0034_eng_f_the_inspired_challenger_657_296.mp3#duration=173&size=1238266"},{"para_id":"657.305","title":"Chapter Ten\u2014Reading the Thoughts of Men\u2019s Hearts","mp3":"\/mp3\/657\/0035_eng_f_chapter_ten_reading_the_thoughts_of_men_s_hearts_657_305.mp3#duration=167&size=1201558"},{"para_id":"657.312","title":"Testimony of Mrs. White\u2019s Translator","mp3":"\/mp3\/657\/0036_eng_f_testimony_of_mrs_white_s_translator_657_312.mp3#duration=243&size=1659928"},{"para_id":"657.324","title":"Confession of R. S. Donnell","mp3":"\/mp3\/657\/0037_eng_f_confession_of_r_s_donnell_657_324.mp3#duration=171&size=1225182"},{"para_id":"657.331","title":"W. H. Saxby\u2019s Testimony","mp3":"\/mp3\/657\/0038_eng_f_w_h_saxby_s_testimony_657_331.mp3#duration=264&size=1784974"},{"para_id":"657.344","title":"Chapter Eleven\u2014Mrs. White\u2019s Personal Life","mp3":"\/mp3\/657\/0039_eng_f_chapter_eleven_mrs_white_s_personal_life_657_344.mp3#duration=174&size=1242145"},{"para_id":"657.352","title":"Firmly Believed She Had Visions","mp3":"\/mp3\/657\/0040_eng_f_firmly_believed_she_had_visions_657_352.mp3#duration=181&size=1287004"},{"para_id":"657.362","title":"The Move to Battle Creek","mp3":"\/mp3\/657\/0041_eng_f_the_move_to_battle_creek_657_362.mp3#duration=246&size=1678253"},{"para_id":"657.374","title":"Her Husband\u2019s Death","mp3":"\/mp3\/657\/0042_eng_f_her_husband_s_death_657_374.mp3#duration=204&size=1426064"},{"para_id":"657.384","title":"She Visits Australia","mp3":"\/mp3\/657\/0043_eng_f_she_visits_australia_657_384.mp3#duration=114&size=887854"},{"para_id":"657.392","title":"Chapter Twelve\u2014Mrs. White in Vision","mp3":"\/mp3\/657\/0044_eng_f_chapter_twelve_mrs_white_in_vision_657_392.mp3#duration=335&size=2209677"},{"para_id":"657.405","title":"Descriptions of Mrs. White in Vision","mp3":"\/mp3\/657\/0045_eng_f_descriptions_of_mrs_white_in_vision_657_405.mp3#duration=152&size=1114069"},{"para_id":"657.416","title":"Physical Effects","mp3":"\/mp3\/657\/0046_eng_f_physical_effects_657_416.mp3#duration=94&size=767885"},{"para_id":"657.425","title":"An Eyewitness Speaks","mp3":"\/mp3\/657\/0047_eng_f_an_eyewitness_speaks_657_425.mp3#duration=303&size=2017220"},{"para_id":"657.436","title":"Significance of Physical Manifestations","mp3":"\/mp3\/657\/0048_eng_f_significance_of_physical_manifestations_657_436.mp3#duration=63&size=579591"},{"para_id":"657.440","title":"\u201cIn the Night Seasons\u201d","mp3":"\/mp3\/657\/0049_eng_f_in_the_night_seasons_657_440.mp3#duration=164&size=1186486"},{"para_id":"657.448","title":"An Inadequate Cause","mp3":"\/mp3\/657\/0050_eng_f_an_inadequate_cause_657_448.mp3#duration=175&size=1249705"},{"para_id":"657.455","title":"Chapter Thirteen\u2014Mrs. White Looks Into the Future","mp3":"\/mp3\/657\/0051_eng_f_chapter_thirteen_mrs_white_looks_into_the_future_657_455.mp3#duration=187&size=1325534"},{"para_id":"657.463","title":"Time-setting Rebukes","mp3":"\/mp3\/657\/0052_eng_f_time_setting_rebukes_657_463.mp3#duration=82&size=694506"},{"para_id":"657.468","title":"Rise of Spiritism","mp3":"\/mp3\/657\/0053_eng_f_rise_of_spiritism_657_468.mp3#duration=203&size=1416453"},{"para_id":"657.479","title":"A Critic Comments","mp3":"\/mp3\/657\/0054_eng_f_a_critic_comments_657_479.mp3#duration=285&size=1911160"},{"para_id":"657.489","title":"A Spectacular Forecast","mp3":"\/mp3\/657\/0055_eng_f_a_spectacular_forecast_657_489.mp3#duration=265&size=1789892"},{"para_id":"657.502","title":"Chapter Fourteen\u2014Questions Some Adventists Ask","mp3":"\/mp3\/657\/0056_eng_f_chapter_fourteen_questions_some_adventists_ask_657_502.mp3#duration=89&size=736742"},{"para_id":"657.507","title":"Moses at the Burning Bush","mp3":"\/mp3\/657\/0057_eng_f_moses_at_the_burning_bush_657_507.mp3#duration=62&size=569860"},{"para_id":"657.509","title":"Why Set Extrascriptural Standards for Her?","mp3":"\/mp3\/657\/0058_eng_f_why_set_extrascriptural_standards_for_her_657_509.mp3#duration=140&size=1039547"},{"para_id":"657.515","title":"Who Is to Measure Agreement?","mp3":"\/mp3\/657\/0059_eng_f_who_is_to_measure_agreement_657_515.mp3#duration=155&size=1128919"},{"para_id":"657.523","title":"Alleged Contradictions","mp3":"\/mp3\/657\/0060_eng_f_alleged_contradictions_657_523.mp3#duration=93&size=757672"},{"para_id":"657.526","title":"The Obvious Moral","mp3":"\/mp3\/657\/0061_eng_f_the_obvious_moral_657_526.mp3#duration=22&size=334593"},{"para_id":"657.529","title":"Mrs. White and Church Membership","mp3":"\/mp3\/657\/0062_eng_f_mrs_white_and_church_membership_657_529.mp3#duration=97&size=779938"},{"para_id":"657.532","title":"Mrs. White and Fanatical Excesses","mp3":"\/mp3\/657\/0063_eng_f_mrs_white_and_fanatical_excesses_657_532.mp3#duration=169&size=1215802"},{"para_id":"657.542","title":"Was Mrs. White a Prophet?","mp3":"\/mp3\/657\/0064_eng_f_was_mrs_white_a_prophet_657_542.mp3#duration=64&size=582398"},{"para_id":"657.544","title":"Are Her Writings of Current Importance?","mp3":"\/mp3\/657\/0065_eng_f_are_her_writings_of_current_importance_657_544.mp3#duration=105&size=831354"},{"para_id":"657.549","title":"Does She Give Extrascriptural Counsels?","mp3":"\/mp3\/657\/0066_eng_f_does_she_give_extrascriptural_counsels_657_549.mp3#duration=104&size=822623"},{"para_id":"657.555","title":"A Specific Situation","mp3":"\/mp3\/657\/0067_eng_f_a_specific_situation_657_555.mp3#duration=210&size=1461549"},{"para_id":"657.565","title":"Reasons for Questions","mp3":"\/mp3\/657\/0068_eng_f_reasons_for_questions_657_565.mp3#duration=116&size=898419"},{"para_id":"657.571","title":"Chapter Fifteen\u2014The Price of Spiritual Leadership","mp3":"\/mp3\/657\/0069_eng_f_chapter_fifteen_the_price_of_spiritual_leadership_657_571.mp3#duration=85&size=710993"},{"para_id":"657.575","title":"Attacks on the Bible","mp3":"\/mp3\/657\/0070_eng_f_attacks_on_the_bible_657_575.mp3#duration=108&size=846584"},{"para_id":"657.579","title":"A Strange Claim","mp3":"\/mp3\/657\/0071_eng_f_a_strange_claim_657_579.mp3#duration=119&size=915027"},{"para_id":"657.584","title":"The Heaviest Price","mp3":"\/mp3\/657\/0072_eng_f_the_heaviest_price_657_584.mp3#duration=184&size=1303827"},{"para_id":"657.595","title":"Chapter Sixteen\u2014Two Typical Objections Considered","mp3":"\/mp3\/657\/0073_eng_f_chapter_sixteen_two_typical_objections_considered_657_595.mp3#duration=109&size=856067"},{"para_id":"657.601","title":"The Record Is Clear","mp3":"\/mp3\/657\/0074_eng_f_the_record_is_clear_657_601.mp3#duration=127&size=960669"},{"para_id":"657.610","title":"A Second Objection","mp3":"\/mp3\/657\/0075_eng_f_a_second_objection_657_610.mp3#duration=315&size=2089770"},{"para_id":"657.625","title":"Chapter Seventeen\u2014Looking Back Over the Record","mp3":"\/mp3\/657\/0076_eng_f_chapter_seventeen_looking_back_over_the_record_657_625.mp3#duration=413&size=2677067"},{"para_id":"657.644","title":"A Personal Testimony","mp3":"\/mp3\/657\/0077_eng_f_a_personal_testimony_657_644.mp3#duration=86&size=717326"}]