Ellen G. White: The Later Elmshaven Years: 1905-1915 (vol. 6)

Arrival of the Promised Testimonies

On Tuesday, December 26, Daniells went to his office early (probably his old office in the West Building) to see whether the communications from Ellen White had come. They had not. A few minutes later one of the physicians from the Battle Creek Sanitarium came to see him. 6BIO 68.2

The physician was in great perplexity of mind. He had been brought up to look upon all messages given by Ellen White as emanating from the Lord. But now he was bewildered and confused. The night before, he, with many other leading Sanitarium workers, had attended a meeting lasting from five o'clock to eleven in which Dr. Kellogg had outlined the recent controversy as he saw it. Kellogg told this group of responsible Sanitarium workers that he believed in the Spirit of Prophecy and believed Ellen White “is a good woman and that she had been inspired of the Lord.” But he continued, “All of the communications which were sent out could not be relied upon as coming from the Lord.”—AGD to G. A. Irwin, December 27, 1905. 6BIO 68.3

“Now,” said the doctor, addressing Elder Daniells, “I want, if possible, that you shall make it plain to me what messages we are to understand are from the Lord, and which ones emanate from men who are influencing Sister White.” 6BIO 68.4

Elder Daniells told him that he could not give him any light on the point, that to him they were “all genuine,” that “they were all either from the Lord or from the devil.” 6BIO 68.5

While the men talked there was a knock on the door, and a messenger handed Elder Daniells a large envelope with “Elmshaven,” Sanitarium, California, as the return address. We will let Daniells tell the story as he did the next day: 6BIO 68.6

“Now,” said I, “Doctor, we will open this envelope, and you shall be the first one to look upon these testimonies; take them, look them over, and tell me whether they are genuine or spurious—whether they were given to her by the Lord, or by some man.” 6BIO 69.1

He took them and looked at the titles, the dates, and the signatures, and handing them over, he said to me, “Well, I cannot tell you whether these are from the Lord or from man, whether they are reliable or unreliable. It looks to me,” said he, “that it is a question of faith on my part as to whether Sister White is a servant of God or a wicked pretender.” 6BIO 69.2

“Well,” said I, “you are just as able to tell me who inspired these communications as I am to tell you; you have seen them first; you know just as much about them as I do; I cannot give you the slightest information that you do not possess. 6BIO 69.3

“Now,” said I, “the only ground for me to occupy is absolute confidence that God is revealing to His servant that which the church needs to understand, and that every single communication which she sends out emanates from God and not from man.”— Ibid. 6BIO 69.4

The physician said that he saw the whole point and that “he must stand fully on this ground.” 6BIO 69.5