The Physical Phenomena Attending the Visions
For Seventh-day Adventists in particular and the world in general, seventy years of work by Ellen G. White have produced so many results of varied kinds that she and her works can be appraised and judged by their fruits alone. It was not so in 1844 and the years that immediately followed. Then evidence was needed of a kind so unusual, so specific, as to arrest attention, produce conviction, and cause men and women to believe in her and her revelations.
BHP 156.5
Physical phenomena, such as are described in the Bible concerning prophets, dreams, and visions, supplied this evidence. They are described in Daniel 10:16-19; Numbers 24:3, 4; 2 Samuel 23:2; 2 Corinthians 12:2-4. The only question that concerns us here is, Did Ellen G. White actually give evidence of these Biblical signs in the realm of physical phenomena?
BHP 157.1
Few, if any, now reading these words, can bear a personal testimony of having seen her in vision when she gave evidence of such physical manifestations. The most and the best we can do is to take the word or testimony of those who did have such firsthand knowledge. This we have in abundance from men whose veracity and honor are beyond question or doubt.
BHP 157.2
The description of the physical phenomena accompanying Mrs. White’s visions which was given by G. I. Butler, General Conference president, in 1874, is representative:
BHP 157.3
“All we ask is that people shall be reasonable. We are prepared to support by hundreds of living truthful witnesses all that we shall claim, so far as facts are concerned, of the manifestation itself, for this thing has not been done in a corner. For nearly thirty years past these visions have been given with greater or less frequency, and have been witnessed by many, oftentimes by unbelievers as well as those believing them. They generally, but not always, occur in the midst of earnest seasons of religious interest while the Spirit of God is specially present, if those can tell who are in attendance. The time Mrs. White is in this condition has varied from fifteen minutes to one hundred and eighty. During this time the heart and pulse continue to beat, the eyes are always wide open, and seem to be gazing at some far-distant object, and are never fixed on any person or thing in the room. They are always directed upward. They exhibit a pleasant expression. There is no ghastly look or any resemblance of fainting. The brightest light may be suddenly brought near her eyes, or feints made as if to thrust something into the eye, and there is never the slightest wink or change of expression on that account; and it is sometimes hours and even days after she comes out of this condition before she recovers her natural sight. She says it seems to her that she comes back into a dark world, yet her eyesight is in nowise injured by her visions.
BHP 157.4
“While she is in vision, her breathing entirely ceases. No breath ever escapes her nostrils or lips when in this condition. This has been proved by many witnesses, among them physicians of skill, and themselves unbelievers in the visions, on some occasions being appointed by a public congregation for the purpose. It has been proved many times by tightly holding the nostrils and mouth with the hand, and by putting a looking-glass before them so close that any escape of the moisture of the breath would be detected. In this condition she often speaks words and short sentences, yet not the slightest breath escapes. When she goes into this condition, there is no appearance of swooning or faintness, her face retains its natural color, and the blood circulates as usual. Often she loses her strength temporarily and reclines or sits; but at other times she stands up. She moves her arms gracefully, and often her face is lighted up with radiance as though the glory of Heaven rested upon her. She is utterly unconscious of every thing going on around her, while she is in vision, having no knowledge whatever of what is said and done in her presence. A person may pinch her flesh, and do things which would cause great and sudden pain in her ordinary condition, and she will not notice it by the slightest tremor.
BHP 158.1
“There are none of the disgusting grimaces or contortions which usually attend spiritualist mediums, but calm, dignified, and impressive, her very appearance strikes the beholder with reverence and solemnity. There is nothing fanatical in her appearance. When she comes out of this condition she speaks and writes from time to time what she has seen while in vision; and the supernatural character of these visions is seen even more clearly in what she thus reveals than in her appearance and condition while in vision, for many things have thus been related which it was impossible for her to know in any other way.”—The Review and Herald, June 9, 1874, p. 201.
BHP 159.1
654
BHP
Believe His Prophets
[{"para_id":"654.2","title":"Believe His Prophets","mp3":"\/mp3\/654\/0000_eng_f_preface_654_2.mp3#duration=99&size=670097"},{"para_id":"654.13","title":"Chapter 1\u2014The Kind of People God Wants","mp3":"\/mp3\/654\/0001_eng_f_chapter_1_the_kind_of_people_god_wants_654_13.mp3#duration=1046&size=6353047"},{"para_id":"654.74","title":"Chapter 2\u2014Three Basic Concepts of Christian","mp3":"\/mp3\/654\/0002_eng_f_chapter_2_three_basic_concepts_of_christian_654_74.mp3#duration=938&size=5700614"},{"para_id":"654.124","title":"Chapter 3\u2014Channels of Communication Between God and Man","mp3":"\/mp3\/654\/0003_eng_f_chapter_3_channels_of_communication_between_god_and_man_654_124.mp3#duration=44&size=339763"},{"para_id":"654.127","title":"God at Various Times Spoke by the Prophets","mp3":"\/mp3\/654\/0004_eng_f_god_at_various_times_spoke_by_the_prophets_654_127.mp3#duration=212&size=1347589"},{"para_id":"654.143","title":"The Call to the Prophetic Office","mp3":"\/mp3\/654\/0005_eng_f_the_call_to_the_prophetic_office_654_143.mp3#duration=145&size=942477"},{"para_id":"654.150","title":"Names Applied to the Messages of the Prophets","mp3":"\/mp3\/654\/0006_eng_f_names_applied_to_the_messages_of_the_prophets_654_150.mp3#duration=93&size=630664"},{"para_id":"654.161","title":"Prophets in the New Testament Church","mp3":"\/mp3\/654\/0007_eng_f_prophets_in_the_new_testament_church_654_161.mp3#duration=343&size=2133394"},{"para_id":"654.182","title":"Prophets in the Remnant Church","mp3":"\/mp3\/654\/0008_eng_f_prophets_in_the_remnant_church_654_182.mp3#duration=222&size=1402757"},{"para_id":"654.200","title":"Chapter 4\u2014Accepting or Rejecting the Prophets","mp3":"\/mp3\/654\/0009_eng_f_chapter_4_accepting_or_rejecting_the_prophets_654_200.mp3#duration=1507&size=9114798"},{"para_id":"654.280","title":"Chapter 5\u2014The Gift of Prophecy in the Advent Movement","mp3":"\/mp3\/654\/0010_eng_f_chapter_5_the_gift_of_prophecy_in_the_advent_movement_654_280.mp3#duration=207&size=1314008"},{"para_id":"654.290","title":"The Call of Ellen Gould Harmon","mp3":"\/mp3\/654\/0011_eng_f_the_call_of_ellen_gould_harmon_654_290.mp3#duration=256&size=1607577"},{"para_id":"654.304","title":"Reactions of Early Pioneers to the Claims of Ellen G. White","mp3":"\/mp3\/654\/0012_eng_f_reactions_of_early_pioneers_to_the_claims_of_ellen_g_white_654_304.mp3#duration=787&size=4793484"},{"para_id":"654.338","title":"The \u201cReview and Herald\u201d and the Visions","mp3":"\/mp3\/654\/0013_eng_f_the_review_and_herald_and_the_visions_654_338.mp3#duration=488&size=3003008"},{"para_id":"654.370","title":"Dr. Brown Comes to Scoff, Flees in Consternation","mp3":"\/mp3\/654\/0014_eng_f_dr_brown_comes_to_scoff_flees_in_consternation_654_370.mp3#duration=116&size=771701"},{"para_id":"654.377","title":"Advent Believers Accept the Seventh-day Sabbath","mp3":"\/mp3\/654\/0015_eng_f_advent_believers_accept_the_seventh_day_sabbath_654_377.mp3#duration=257&size=1614115"},{"para_id":"654.393","title":"Chapter 6\u2014Four Bible Tests of a True Prophet","mp3":"\/mp3\/654\/0016_eng_f_chapter_6_four_bible_tests_of_a_true_prophet_654_393.mp3#duration=242&size=1524048"},{"para_id":"654.408","title":"The Test of Fulfilled Predictions","mp3":"\/mp3\/654\/0017_eng_f_the_test_of_fulfilled_predictions_654_408.mp3#duration=707&size=4318215"},{"para_id":"654.464","title":"Did Mrs. White\u2019s Predictions Always Come to Pass?","mp3":"\/mp3\/654\/0018_eng_f_did_mrs_white_s_predictions_always_come_to_pass_654_464.mp3#duration=376&size=2331187"},{"para_id":"654.493","title":"The Test of Divine Guidance in Times of Crisis in the Advent Movement","mp3":"\/mp3\/654\/0019_eng_f_the_test_of_divine_guidance_in_times_of_crisis_in_the_advent_movement_654_493.mp3#duration=461&size=2842870"},{"para_id":"654.522","title":"The Test of Agreement With the Bible","mp3":"\/mp3\/654\/0020_eng_f_the_test_of_agreement_with_the_bible_654_522.mp3#duration=215&size=1364582"},{"para_id":"654.539","title":"The Test of the Kind of Fruit Borne in Life and Works","mp3":"\/mp3\/654\/0021_eng_f_the_test_of_the_kind_of_fruit_borne_in_life_and_works_654_539.mp3#duration=815&size=4961719"},{"para_id":"654.582","title":"Chapter 7\u2014Evidences That Ellen G. White Was Used by God","mp3":"\/mp3\/654\/0022_eng_f_chapter_7_evidences_that_ellen_g_white_was_used_by_god_654_582.mp3#duration=165&size=1063718"},{"para_id":"654.596","title":"The Timeliness of the Messages","mp3":"\/mp3\/654\/0023_eng_f_the_timeliness_of_the_messages_654_596.mp3#duration=757&size=4615153"},{"para_id":"654.642","title":"The Practical Nature of the Messages","mp3":"\/mp3\/654\/0024_eng_f_the_practical_nature_of_the_messages_654_642.mp3#duration=503&size=3091358"},{"para_id":"654.668","title":"Chapter 8\u2014God Revealed Secrets Through Ellen G. White","mp3":"\/mp3\/654\/0025_eng_f_chapter_8_god_revealed_secrets_through_ellen_g_white_654_668.mp3#duration=128&size=840355"},{"para_id":"654.676","title":"The Certainty of the Messages","mp3":"\/mp3\/654\/0026_eng_f_the_certainty_of_the_messages_654_676.mp3#duration=1067&size=6478741"},{"para_id":"654.732","title":"Chapter 9\u2014The Witness of Contemporaries","mp3":"\/mp3\/654\/0027_eng_f_chapter_9_the_witness_of_contemporaries_654_732.mp3#duration=47&size=354325"},{"para_id":"654.735","title":"Recognized by Contemporaries","mp3":"\/mp3\/654\/0028_eng_f_recognized_by_contemporaries_654_735.mp3#duration=1590&size=9616485"},{"para_id":"654.813","title":"The Relation to Outside Influences","mp3":"\/mp3\/654\/0029_eng_f_the_relation_to_outside_influences_654_813.mp3#duration=563&size=3453799"},{"para_id":"654.842","title":"The Physical Phenomena Attending the Visions","mp3":"\/mp3\/654\/0030_eng_f_the_physical_phenomena_attending_the_visions_654_842.mp3#duration=308&size=1924260"},{"para_id":"654.856","title":"Chapter 10\u2014The Relation of Ellen G. White to the Bible","mp3":"\/mp3\/654\/0031_eng_f_chapter_10_the_relation_of_ellen_g_white_to_the_bible_654_856.mp3#duration=223&size=1410963"},{"para_id":"654.868","title":"Ellen G. White Exalted the Scriptures","mp3":"\/mp3\/654\/0032_eng_f_ellen_g_white_exalted_the_scriptures_654_868.mp3#duration=416&size=2570261"},{"para_id":"654.903","title":"Spirit of Prophecy Relationship to Development of Doctrine","mp3":"\/mp3\/654\/0033_eng_f_spirit_of_prophecy_relationship_to_development_of_doctrine_654_903.mp3#duration=243&size=1534144"},{"para_id":"654.917","title":"The Greater Light and the Lesser Light","mp3":"\/mp3\/654\/0034_eng_f_the_greater_light_and_the_lesser_light_654_917.mp3#duration=121&size=801756"},{"para_id":"654.928","title":"What Others Have Said of the Relation of the Testimonies to the Bible","mp3":"\/mp3\/654\/0035_eng_f_what_others_have_said_of_the_relation_of_the_testimonies_to_the_bible_654_928.mp3#duration=1352&size=8187077"},{"para_id":"654.999","title":"Chapter 11\u2014Ellen G. White\u2019s Attitude Toward Her Own Writings","mp3":"\/mp3\/654\/0036_eng_f_chapter_11_ellen_g_white_s_attitude_toward_her_own_writings_654_999.mp3#duration=81&size=560089"},{"para_id":"654.1006","title":"Ellen G. White\u2019s Claim to Inspiration","mp3":"\/mp3\/654\/0037_eng_f_ellen_g_white_s_claim_to_inspiration_654_1006.mp3#duration=263&size=1653259"},{"para_id":"654.1026","title":"Ellen G. White\u2019s Definition of Inspiration","mp3":"\/mp3\/654\/0038_eng_f_ellen_g_white_s_definition_of_inspiration_654_1026.mp3#duration=998&size=6060518"},{"para_id":"654.1089","title":"Inspiration and Infallibility","mp3":"\/mp3\/654\/0039_eng_f_inspiration_and_infallibility_654_1089.mp3#duration=691&size=4218176"},{"para_id":"654.1134","title":"How the Writings Came to Be","mp3":"\/mp3\/654\/0040_eng_f_how_the_writings_came_to_be_654_1134.mp3#duration=40&size=312578"},{"para_id":"654.1136","title":"Purpose of the Testimonies","mp3":"\/mp3\/654\/0041_eng_f_purpose_of_the_testimonies_654_1136.mp3#duration=290&size=1814182"},{"para_id":"654.1152","title":"Attitudes Toward the Testimonies","mp3":"\/mp3\/654\/0042_eng_f_attitudes_toward_the_testimonies_654_1152.mp3#duration=138&size=898962"},{"para_id":"654.1164","title":"Wrong Use of the Testimonies","mp3":"\/mp3\/654\/0043_eng_f_wrong_use_of_the_testimonies_654_1164.mp3#duration=269&size=1689513"},{"para_id":"654.1183","title":"Chapter 12\u2014Ellen G. White\u2019s Message on Health","mp3":"\/mp3\/654\/0044_eng_f_chapter_12_ellen_g_white_s_message_on_health_654_1183.mp3#duration=3765&size=22674289"},{"para_id":"654.1432","title":"Chapter 13\u2014Ellen G. White\u2019s Message on Dress ","mp3":"\/mp3\/654\/0045_eng_f_chapter_13_ellen_g_white_s_message_on_dress_654_1432.mp3#duration=389&size=2405758"},{"para_id":"654.1462","title":"Reviewing the Past","mp3":"\/mp3\/654\/0046_eng_f_reviewing_the_past_654_1462.mp3#duration=240&size=1515904"},{"para_id":"654.1475","title":"Reasons for Reform","mp3":"\/mp3\/654\/0047_eng_f_reasons_for_reform_654_1475.mp3#duration=286&size=1790333"},{"para_id":"654.1497","title":"Instruction From Ellen G. White","mp3":"\/mp3\/654\/0048_eng_f_instruction_from_ellen_g_white_654_1497.mp3#duration=296&size=1850120"},{"para_id":"654.1516","title":"Avoiding Extremes","mp3":"\/mp3\/654\/0049_eng_f_avoiding_extremes_654_1516.mp3#duration=397&size=2455134"},{"para_id":"654.1544","title":"Renewal of Agitation Discouraged","mp3":"\/mp3\/654\/0050_eng_f_renewal_of_agitation_discouraged_654_1544.mp3#duration=287&size=1797885"},{"para_id":"654.1558","title":"Fundamental Principles","mp3":"\/mp3\/654\/0051_eng_f_fundamental_principles_654_1558.mp3#duration=377&size=2336928"},{"para_id":"654.1580","title":"Appropriate Length of Dress","mp3":"\/mp3\/654\/0052_eng_f_appropriate_length_of_dress_654_1580.mp3#duration=250&size=1572759"},{"para_id":"654.1593","title":"Represents Character","mp3":"\/mp3\/654\/0053_eng_f_represents_character_654_1593.mp3#duration=353&size=2192113"},{"para_id":"654.1612","title":"Chapter 14\u2014What Manner of Persons Ought We to Be?","mp3":"\/mp3\/654\/0054_eng_f_chapter_14_what_manner_of_persons_ought_we_to_be_654_1612.mp3#duration=1384&size=8377987"},{"para_id":"654.1710","title":"Chapter 15\u2014My Attitude on the Life and Work of Ellen G. White","mp3":"\/mp3\/654\/0055_eng_f_chapter_15_my_attitude_on_the_life_and_work_of_ellen_g_white_654_1710.mp3#duration=664&size=4060486"},{"para_id":"654.1752","title":"My Salvation and the Writings of Ellen G. White","mp3":"\/mp3\/654\/0056_eng_f_my_salvation_and_the_writings_of_ellen_g_white_654_1752.mp3#duration=51&size=382081"},{"para_id":"654.1756","title":"What Doth the Lord Require?","mp3":"\/mp3\/654\/0057_eng_f_what_doth_the_lord_require_654_1756.mp3#duration=291&size=1819297"},{"para_id":"654.1771","title":"The Conclusion From Her Own Statement","mp3":"\/mp3\/654\/0058_eng_f_the_conclusion_from_her_own_statement_654_1771.mp3#duration=468&size=2881110"},{"para_id":"654.1801","title":"Righteousness by Faith\u2014the Latter Rain and the Loud Cry","mp3":"\/mp3\/654\/0059_eng_f_righteousness_by_faith_the_latter_rain_and_the_loud_cry_654_1801.mp3#duration=227&size=1435952"},{"para_id":"654.1817","title":"The Attitude of the Brethren Toward the Writings of Ellen G. White","mp3":"\/mp3\/654\/0060_eng_f_the_attitude_of_the_brethren_toward_the_writings_of_ellen_g_white_654_1817.mp3#duration=454&size=2797272"},{"para_id":"654.1848","title":"My Attitude Toward the Life and Work of Ellen G. White","mp3":"\/mp3\/654\/0061_eng_f_my_attitude_toward_the_life_and_work_of_ellen_g_white_654_1848.mp3#duration=810&size=4936698"}]