Who Stoutly Opposed the False Theory?
Elder Turner began teaching his “no-more-mercy” doctrine in Paris, Maine, and for a little time had quite a following in that section of country. As there was such a complete shut door of access to the people outside of Adventists, whether professor or nonprofessor, many quite naturally drifted into Turner’s view of the subject.
GSAM 221.1
Lest the term Adventists should be misunderstood, we will hereafter speak of this people as First-day Adventists; and it was many of this class that were accepting Mr. Turner’s views. They had not as yet seen or heard the Sabbath truth, neither had they heard of the third angel’s message. It is of these that Mrs. White speaks thus in one of her publications:—
GSAM 221.2
“After the passing of the time of expectation in 1844, Adventists still believed the Saviour’s coming to be very near; they held that they had reached an important crisis, and that the work of Christ as man’s intercessor before God had ceased. Having given the warning of the judgment near, they felt that their work for the world was done, and they lost their burden of soul for the salvation of sinners, while the bold, blasphemous scoffing of the ungodly seemed to them another evidence that the Spirit of God had been withdrawn from the rejecters of his mercy. All this confirmed them in the belief that probation had ended, or, as they expressed it, ‘the door of mercy was shut.’ As has been stated, Adventists were for a short time united in the belief that the door of mercy was shut.”
GSAM 221.3
In this quotation Mrs. White states the position taken by the First-day Adventists. She does not even intimate that she believed it. As shown above, the doctrine was first taught by Joseph Turner, at Paris, Maine. Mrs. White (then Miss Harmon) met Joseph Turner at the above-named place in the early spring of 1845, and heard him declare his doctrine of “no more manual labor for Adventists, and no more mercy for sinners,” and plainly told him he was “teaching a false doctrine; that there was still mercy for sinners, and for those who had not understandingly rejected the truth.”
GSAM 222.1
1140
GSAM
The Great Second Advent Movement: Its Rise and Progress
[{"para_id":"1140.19","title":"Preface","mp3":"\/mp3\/1140\/0003_eng_m_preface_1140_19.mp3#duration=291&size=1838724"},{"para_id":"1140.29","title":"Preface to the 1992 Edition","mp3":"\/mp3\/1140\/0004_eng_m_preface_to_the_1992_edition_1140_29.mp3#duration=1245&size=7563605"},{"para_id":"1140.88","title":"Chapter 1 \u2014 Introductory","mp3":"\/mp3\/1140\/0017_eng_m_chapter_1_introductory_1140_88.mp3#duration=2607&size=11446422"},{"para_id":"1140.210","title":"Chapter 2 \u2014 The Plan of Salvation Unfolded","mp3":"\/mp3\/1140\/0043_eng_m_chapter_2_the_plan_of_salvation_unfolded_1140_210.mp3#duration=2997&size=13128865"},{"para_id":"1140.321","title":"Chapter 3 \u2014 The Coming of the Promised Seed","mp3":"\/mp3\/1140\/0069_eng_m_chapter_3_the_coming_of_the_promised_seed_1140_321.mp3#duration=3026&size=13361638"},{"para_id":"1140.445","title":"Chapter 4 \u2014 The Time of the End","mp3":"\/mp3\/1140\/0097_eng_m_chapter_4_the_time_of_the_end_1140_445.mp3#duration=2704&size=11830750"},{"para_id":"1140.547","title":"Chapter 5 \u2014 The Second Advent Message","mp3":"\/mp3\/1140\/0120_eng_m_chapter_5_the_second_advent_message_1140_547.mp3#duration=2324&size=9979862"},{"para_id":"1140.655","title":"Chapter 6 \u2014 The Message and the Messengers","mp3":"\/mp3\/1140\/0142_eng_m_chapter_6_the_message_and_the_messengers_1140_655.mp3#duration=2773&size=11824393"},{"para_id":"1140.768","title":"Chapter 7 \u2014 The Rapid Advancement of the Message","mp3":"\/mp3\/1140\/0160_eng_m_chapter_7_the_rapid_advancement_of_the_message_1140_768.mp3#duration=1220&size=5258521"},{"para_id":"1140.815","title":"Chapter 8 \u2014 The Marriage Supper of the Lamb","mp3":"\/mp3\/1140\/0172_eng_m_chapter_8_the_marriage_supper_of_the_lamb_1140_815.mp3#duration=1950&size=8398445"},{"para_id":"1140.909","title":"Chapter 9 \u2014 The Tarrying Time","mp3":"\/mp3\/1140\/0192_eng_m_chapter_9_the_tarrying_time_1140_909.mp3#duration=1724&size=7452349"},{"para_id":"1140.979","title":"Chapter 10 \u2014 The Midnight Cry","mp3":"\/mp3\/1140\/0207_eng_m_chapter_10_the_midnight_cry_1140_979.mp3#duration=1552&size=6754433"},{"para_id":"1140.1042","title":"Chapter 11 \u2014 The Second Angel\u2019s Message","mp3":"\/mp3\/1140\/0220_eng_m_chapter_11_the_second_angel_s_message_1140_1042.mp3#duration=1898&size=8206110"},{"para_id":"1140.1127","title":"Chapter 12 \u2014 The Disappointment\u2014The Bitter Book","mp3":"\/mp3\/1140\/0241_eng_m_chapter_12_the_disappointment_the_bitter_book_1140_1127.mp3#duration=2008&size=8711552"},{"para_id":"1140.1213","title":"Chapter 13 \u2014 Tokens of Divine Guidance","mp3":"\/mp3\/1140\/0261_eng_m_chapter_13_tokens_of_divine_guidance_1140_1213.mp3#duration=2503&size=10802474"},{"para_id":"1140.1315","title":"Chapter 14 \u2014 The Shut Door","mp3":"\/mp3\/1140\/0285_eng_m_chapter_14_the_shut_door_1140_1315.mp3#duration=3206&size=13865105"},{"para_id":"1140.1453","title":"Chapter 15 \u2014 Increasing Light and Greater Wonders","mp3":"\/mp3\/1140\/0313_eng_m_chapter_15_increasing_light_and_greater_wonders_1140_1453.mp3#duration=5047&size=20280460"},{"para_id":"1140.1526","title":"Chapter 16 \u2014 The Third Angel\u2019s Message","mp3":"\/mp3\/1140\/0327_eng_m_chapter_16_the_third_angel_s_message_1140_1526.mp3#duration=7496&size=30079943"},{"para_id":"1140.1644","title":"Chapter 17 \u2014 The Truth Advanced Under Difficulties","mp3":"\/mp3\/1140\/0354_eng_m_chapter_17_the_truth_advanced_under_difficulties_1140_1644.mp3#duration=1998&size=8658557"},{"para_id":"1140.1758","title":"Chapter 18 \u2014 Providence of God in the Publishing Work","mp3":"\/mp3\/1140\/0379_eng_m_chapter_18_providence_of_god_in_the_publishing_work_1140_1758.mp3#duration=2506&size=10920210"},{"para_id":"1140.1897","title":"Chapter 19 \u2014 \u201cBy Their Fruits Ye Shall Know Them\u201d","mp3":"\/mp3\/1140\/0418_eng_m_chapter_19_by_their_fruits_ye_shall_know_them_1140_1897.mp3#duration=1750&size=7618767"},{"para_id":"1140.1967","title":"Chapter 20 \u2014 Sacrifices in the Early Work","mp3":"\/mp3\/1140\/0428_eng_m_chapter_20_sacrifices_in_the_early_work_1140_1967.mp3#duration=1550&size=6767450"},{"para_id":"1140.2047","title":"Chapter 21 \u2014 The Guiding Hand in the Work","mp3":"\/mp3\/1140\/0448_eng_m_chapter_21_the_guiding_hand_in_the_work_1140_2047.mp3#duration=3123&size=13454398"},{"para_id":"1140.2185","title":"Chapter 22 \u2014 Organization","mp3":"\/mp3\/1140\/0482_eng_m_chapter_22_organization_1140_2185.mp3#duration=1944&size=8469692"},{"para_id":"1140.2305","title":"Chapter 23 \u2014 Health Institutions","mp3":"\/mp3\/1140\/0519_eng_m_chapter_23_health_institutions_1140_2305.mp3#duration=2482&size=10767173"},{"para_id":"1140.2450","title":"Chapter 24 \u2014 Other Predictions Fulfilled","mp3":"\/mp3\/1140\/0557_eng_m_chapter_24_other_predictions_fulfilled_1140_2450.mp3#duration=1926&size=8368038"},{"para_id":"1140.2559","title":"Chapter 25 \u2014 Educational Institutions","mp3":"\/mp3\/1140\/0588_eng_m_chapter_25_educational_institutions_1140_2559.mp3#duration=1618&size=7076341"},{"para_id":"1140.2647","title":"Chapter 26 \u2014 Our Foreign Missions","mp3":"\/mp3\/1140\/0613_eng_m_chapter_26_our_foreign_missions_1140_2647.mp3#duration=5541&size=23900837"},{"para_id":"1140.2957","title":"Chapter 27 \u2014 Other Testimonies Confirmed","mp3":"\/mp3\/1140\/0707_eng_m_chapter_27_other_testimonies_confirmed_1140_2957.mp3#duration=2725&size=11814726"},{"para_id":"1140.3100","title":"Chapter 28 \u2014 A Door That No Man Can Shut","mp3":"\/mp3\/1140\/0739_eng_m_chapter_28_a_door_that_no_man_can_shut_1140_3100.mp3#duration=1714&size=7442135"},{"para_id":"1140.3182","title":"Appendix A \u2014 Some Individual Experience","mp3":"\/mp3\/1140\/0755_eng_m_appendix_a_some_individual_experience_1140_3182.mp3#duration=5133&size=22148556"},{"para_id":"1140.3188","title":"PREFACE TO APPENDIX A","mp3":"\/mp3\/1140\/0756_eng_m_preface_to_appendix_a_1140_3188.mp3#duration=281&size=1775136"},{"para_id":"1140.3202","title":"PART ONE","mp3":"\/mp3\/1140\/0757_eng_m_part_one_1140_3202.mp3#duration=4832&size=29086712"},{"para_id":"1140.3383","title":"PART TWO","mp3":"\/mp3\/1140\/0780_eng_m_part_two_1140_3383.mp3#duration=5338&size=23077243"},{"para_id":"1140.3584","title":"Apostolic and Advent Experience","mp3":"\/mp3\/1140\/0808_eng_m_apostolic_and_advent_experience_1140_3584.mp3#duration=2053&size=8904729"},{"para_id":"1140.3650","title":"Appendix B \u2014 Summary of Key Dates in Loughborough\u2019s Life Extracted from The Great Second Advent Movement","mp3":"\/mp3\/1140\/0817_eng_m_appendix_b_summary_of_key_dates_in_loughborough_s_life_extracted_from_th_1140_3650.mp3#duration=5338&size=23071916"},{"para_id":"1140.3675","title":"Appendix C \u2014 Some 1992 Observations on the Book\u2014The Great Second Advent Movement","mp3":"\/mp3\/1140\/0818_eng_m_appendix_c_some_1992_observations_on_the_book_the_great_second_adven_1140_3675.mp3#duration=2053&size=8904455"}]